All Creation Myths Need a Devil

29 Sep

Whatever your feelings regarding Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg before seeing The Social Network, you’re bound to have them intensified.

That’s because the film, which details the early days of the site, portrays the guy as both a nerd superhero and total jerk, and it’s up to the viewer to decide which label sticks.

For me, it’s not an all or nothing answer, and I suspect I won’t be alone when I say I started on one side and moved more to the middle by film’s end, but never crossed all the way over.

Regardless of where you come down on the debate, however, it’s hard to deny that The Social Network makes great entertainment out of one of this generation’s biggest Internet success stories.

What’s it all about?

When the movie begins, it’s the fall of 2003, and Mark Zuckerberg (Jesse Eisenberg), a socially awkward Harvard sophomore who resents but longs to be part of the cool crowd, has just been dumped by his girlfriend.

Drunk and seething with anger, he takes to the Internet, creating a site called Facemash, which asks his fellow students to compare their classmates and decide which is more attractive.

Suffice it to say, the site is such a hit that it crashes the school’s server — and garners enough attention that soon Zuckerberg is approached by rich identical twins Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss (Armie Hammer, playing both roles), who want him to help them build an exclusive social network. Zuck has other plans, however, and he decides to build a separate site, a better site,, which he hopes — he knows — will beat his privileged, cooler classmates at their own game.

Yes, the site is a huge hit almost instantaneously.

The Winklevoss twins believe Zuck stole their idea, and he rubs their nose in it by expanding thefacebook and growing it bigger and bigger — so big that it attracts the interest of Napster founder Shawn Parker (Justin Timberlake), who seizes the opportunity to make Facebook the billion-dollar company that Napster never was.

With Parker’s help and guidance, Zuck almost single-mindedly pursues his goal of making thefacebook (later renamed simply Facebook) the biggest site in the world, never obsessing about money or any other distractions — unlike his friend and partner Eduardo Saverin (Andrew Garfield), whose fruitless attempts to monetize the site drive a wedge between the two friends. (“Like fashion, it’s never finished,” Zuck tells Saverin. “Yes,” Eduardo responds, “but they still make money selling pants.”)

By pursuing his goal so doggedly, Zuck reveals himself as being vengeful, selfish, and cruel. He not only ostracizes the Winklevoss twins, but by film’s end, he’s no longer friends with Saverin or partners with Parker.

Why is it so good?

The Social Network was written by Aaron Sorkin, directed by David Fincher, and (loosely) based on the book The Accidental Billionaires, by Ben Mezrich, and like the book, it’s a fast-paced and highly enjoyable story, told in exciting and compelling fashion.

The film uses two depositions (one with Saverin’s lawsuit, and one with the Winklevoss twins’ lawsuit) as a framing device, but sticks to a mostly linear narrative.

Sure, the film gets a bit exhausting about 3/4 of the way in, but that’s because Sorkin packs so much into his screenplay, and Fincher manages to cram it all into this 120-minute-long film.

In the lead roles, all are excellent.

Timberlake is suave and charming (it’s no wonder he’s able to assume the role of Dr. Landy to Zuck’s Brian Wilson), and Garfield makes a sympathetic and betrayed Saverin, but this is really Eisenberg’s film. His portrayal of Zuck is so balls-out rude and, well, cool that you can’t help but root for him and the site to succeed, and laugh when his opponents don’t get their way. (It should be noted that Zuck comes off as much more of an asshole here than he does in the book.)

And yet, Eisenberg also shows some heart at Zuck’s core, some pain in his success, which only serves to put a fine-point on the irony of a guy with no friends who starts a huge network that’s centered around that very word.

(As a lawyer played by Rashida Jones says to Mark at one point, “You’re not an asshole. You’re just trying so hard to be one.”)

Did everything in the film happen as it’s shown? No.

The story is essentially told from multiple points of view, and Zuck himself says, “That’s not what happened.”

That said, as Jones’ character notes, “Creation myths need a devil.” By giving Zuck more of that role here than he had in reality and in Mezrich’s book, I think it only makes his legend grow larger — in a good way.

Call The Social Network the real Revenge of the Nerd if you will, but it’s clear from the film that Zuck’s the one having the last laugh right now, with few regrets.

I’m giving The Social Network an A–, and I look forward to seeing it again.

15 Responses to “All Creation Myths Need a Devil”


  1. I’d Like to Thank You for the Year « Martin's Musings - March 12, 2012

    […] things like the merits of Google+, Klout, or Rebecca Black, or whether The King’s Speech or The Social Network was a better movie, and doing so via email, on Twitter, or while sitting in a hot tub in Park City, […]

  2. Cold Case « Martin's Musings - March 12, 2012

    […] then there’s Mara (last seen as Mark Zuckerberg’s ex-girlfriend in The Social Network), who makes a real bad ass, kick ass […]

  3. Johnny and Clyde « Martin's Musings - March 18, 2012

    […] film isn’t graphic about his relationship with Clyde Tolson (The Social Network‘s Armie Hammer), Hoover’s Associate Director, protégé, and supposed lover, but it […]

  4. When Dylan Met Jamie … « Martin's Musings - March 18, 2012

    […] impressive dramatic performances in The Social Network and Black Swan, it’s fun to see these two back in lightweight […]

  5. Hey Zuck … Leave Facebook Alone, Will Ya? « Martin's Musings - May 18, 2012

    […] I’m sure he liked taking more attention away from The Social Network […]

  6. People Who Don’t Like Social Media Must Not Like Birthdays Either « Martin's Musings - June 11, 2012

    […] I may not like everything Mark Zuckerberg does to Facebook, but birthdays he got right, almost from the very beginning. […]

  7. All This Is About Getting Even? « Martin's Musings - July 3, 2012

    […] his version of Peter/Spidey. Andrew Garfield, previously best known for playing Eduardo Saverin in The Social Network, gives a charming and sympathetic performance that makes you root for him and enjoy going along for […]

  8. With Age Comes Exhaustion « Martin's Musings - July 12, 2012

    […] And then, in a bit of Midnight in Paris–style magic, John runs into Jack (Jesse Eisenberg, from The Social Network) on the street. Jack is actually John’s younger self — which means that in his early 20s, […]

  9. Worth Fighting For « Martin's Musings - November 17, 2012

    […] Fighter is about boxing like The Social Network is about Facebook — which is to say, that’s not really the point of the […]

  10. Everybody’s Searching for Something | Martin's Musings - June 6, 2013

    […] pegs find a way to rally their troops, compete against cocky opponents (including one played by The Social Network’s Max Minghella), and prove the naysayers wrong (again, of course they […]

  11. Spirit Walker, Texas Ranger | Martin's Musings - July 2, 2013

    […] genre, the Lone Ranger is a reluctant hero. But Hammer, best known for playing the Winklevii in The Social Network, isn’t given much pathos or agita to deal with. Reid is just a man out of his element — and […]

  12. The Lone Ranger: Movie Review | Popblerd!! - July 3, 2013

    […] genre, the Lone Ranger is a reluctant hero. But Hammer, best known for playing the Winklevii in The Social Network, isn’t given much pathos or agita to deal with. Reid is just a man out of his element — and […]

  13. The Dog Days (and Dog Movies) of Summer Have Come and Gone | Martin's Musings - September 8, 2015

    […] Man of Steel himself, Henry Cavill, playing a dashing, straight-faced but witty, American spy, and erstwhile Winklevoss twins Armie Hammer playing a more stoic, all-business Russian one. Alicia Vikander makes for an adorable […]

  14. 2010’s Entertainment Stays with Me | Martin's Musings - December 7, 2019

    […] The Social Network (which I’ve seen three times) 2. The Fighter 3. Inception 4. 127 Hours 5. The Kids Are All […]

  15. Wrapping Up a Decade at the Movies with 20 Favorite Films | Martin's Musings - December 10, 2019

    […] The Social Network (2010) […]

What say you? Leave a comment here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: