Blood’s Been Spilled to Afford Us This Moment

9 Nov

After a long, grueling election cycle, it’s good to see a movie that takes our mind off it entirely.

A movie about a leader trying to unite a divided nation, who seeks to free a section of the country’s population, and who must fight against stubborn and backwards-leaning political opponents to accomplish that goal.

One that has absolutely nothing to do with current topics of debate.

If you couldn’t tell, that’s intended to be sarcasm. Affectionate sarcasm.

Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln puts the spotlight on the political scene in 1865, when the President (Daniel Day-Lewis, giving a predictably good performance) waged a tricky political battle in order to end the Civil War and slavery. Doubted by even his most loyal supporters, who told him he could do one or the other but not both, the film shows how Lincoln shrewdly persuaded members of both parties to support the 13th Amendment, and how that lead to the end of the war.

Lincoln is based on Doris Kearns Goodwin’s Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln. But by zeroing in on just those few months of debate, and not covering Lincoln’s entire life, Spielberg allows his film to dig deep into the political machinations that often go along with significant change, and to really let us experience what that time could have been like.

To say the stakes were high is an understatement. Lincoln had just been reelected, and he was enjoying a high approval rating. “No one’s ever been loved so much by the people,” his wife, Mary Todd (Sally Field), tells the President. “Don’t waste that power.” As if he needed more pressure. Lincoln knows he has nothing less than “the fate of human dignity” (not to mention the lives of all those soldiers out on the battlefield) in his hands.

Unlike other portraits of Lincoln — statesman, lawyer, vampire hunter — this movie shows us the man as a thinker and strategist, one who needs to accomplish his goal of moving the needle forward not by conventional combat but by debate, even if that means extending the war in the process.

Lincoln focuses equally on the loud, bombastic speechifying in Congress as much as it does on the private meetings that take place in drab boardrooms with advisors and at the homes of members of the House of Representatives, putting a fine point on where the real work of government takes place. It’s completely engrossing.

And all through that, Day-Lewis wears Lincoln’s gravitas and acknowledgement of his possible place in history as part of his costume. He’s often seen hunched over, contemplative, deep in thought … quoting Shakespeare, and asking (in that folksy voice) questions of anyone who’ll listen and weigh the sides with him. For example, “Do you think we choose to be born, or are we fitted into the times we’re born into?” he asks two lowly communications workers.

Yet, Lincoln was also a man with great power, one who could make a persuasive, fiery argument and who could convince even a more fervent abolitionist like Thaddeus Stevens (the excellent Tommy Lee Jones) to tone down his own rhetoric for the good of the cause. And he knew he didn’t have time to waste.

Lincoln didn’t get the amendment passed all by himself, of course. The film shows, sometimes in humorous fashion, how the President’s minions and “teammates” often had to pull strings and make promises to get the job done. (It’s worth noting here that the impressive and large cast also includes James Spader, David Strathairn, Jackie Earle Haley, John Hawkes, Tim Blake Nelson, Hal Holbrook, Lee Pace, and Bruce McGill.)

The screenplay by Tony Kushner (Munich), full of heated lines like “Congress must never declare equal those who God has created unequal,” draws expected parallels to modern-day issues like gay rights and health care, and illustrates effectively that the language used in the debate over human rights has not changed much in 150 years. (Though it is fascinating how in the 1860s, it was the Republicans who were liberal and for equal rights, and the Democrats who were more conservative and resistant to such things. That much has completely flip-flopped.)

Spielberg treats the subject with appropriate reverence, without being self-important (like he’s done in films like War Horse). He’s made Lincoln a history lesson that engages and entertains, and does so urgently, so we feel the significance of the moment and can rejoice in the way those times were a-changin’ — and still do today.

Lincoln is one of the year’s best films, and I’m giving it an A–.

Will you be voting for Lincoln? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.

6 Responses to “Blood’s Been Spilled to Afford Us This Moment”


  1. It’s Just a Bloody Movie « Martin's Musings - November 29, 2012

    […] as Lincoln provided insights into the President by focusing only on a few months of his life, Hitchcock uses […]

  2. 2012 Was a Masterful Year for the Movies « Martin's Musings - December 21, 2012

    […] Lincoln Led by a predictably good Daniel Day-Lewis, Steven Spielberg’s film zeroes in on just a few […]

  3. What Were My Top 12 Blog Posts of 2012? « Martin's Musings - December 27, 2012

    […] I wrote a lot of movie reviews, but the most-viewed ones weren’t Oscar contenders like Lincoln or Argo, or big blockbusters like The Dark Knight Rises. I wrote about social media a bit, but my […]

  4. It’s Her Against the World « Martin's Musings - January 11, 2013

    […] the military operations to show the intellectual work involved in such an operation — much like Lincoln showed the backroom dealings and negotiations that led to the passing of the 13th Amendment. […]

  5. Argo Get Yourself Some Oscars | Martin's Musings - February 22, 2013

    […] could be a surprise winner here. My hunch is that this will be a way for the Academy to reward Lincoln, the most nominated movie with 12 noms, with a kind of second-place award. But let’s not […]

  6. The Best Movies of 2014 Were Quite the Present | Martin's Musings - December 29, 2014

    […] in on just that event, letting three months represent the whole of King’s life (a la Lincoln). David Oyelowo, in an impressive performance, lets us see the man in full: His ability to lead and […]

What say you? Leave a comment here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: